Well, to be honest it lies somewhere inbetween those two poles, although thankfully it's closer to the latter than the former in the amusement stakes. The episode begins, and virtually ends, with a pudding crisis, as Touma visits the Minami household on two occasions to request to stay the night after falling out with her brother on account of him eating her pudding (with the second occasion all but turning to domestic violence inside her immediate family). However, this only causes her to become embroiled in an entirely seperate pudding-related incident there, which is resolved with relative ease. The second chunk of this episode was a rather more surreal affair involving a surfeit of apples, and some kind of baked apple drama that I really couldn't quite wrap my head around.
However, my personal favourite segment of this instalment saw Kana, Chiaki and Touma trying to finish off cooking a curry started by Haruka, while she in turn tried to talk Touma's brother Natsuki through a recipe for sweets. As the two parties yell out indredients as part of their respective conversations, so confusion ensues with inevitable (yet still amusing) consequences.
If I had to label any criticism at this particular episode of Minami-ke Okaeri, it would be on account of its predictability - The ending to each of the set-ups (aside from that aforementioned surreal baked apple scenario) was telegraphed well in advance, taking a little of the lustre from those gags. Still, at least they were jokes, and in the best of Minami-ke traditions to boot - They got a smile out of me, so I'll let their obvious nature slide for now. In other words, while this wasn't quite as good as the last episode of this series, it was still a big improvement over its opener, and I'm now finding myself in the groove of quite enjoying the series as I did the original Minami-ke.
I was rather disappointed in this episode. As you said, jokes were telegraphed and expected jokes are normally not funny. Plus, I just didn't get the pudding crisis nor the apple crisis. I do understand the place for said items in Japanese culture, but that did not make it funny to me. Well, not everything can be a home run.
ReplyDeleteI still have a problem with the animation/chara design quality, it REALLY is gratingly bad.
ReplyDeleteOn the positive, I liked the joke setups. The pudding bit reminded smacked of a Toki o Kakeru Shoujo in-joke.
The cooking sequence was funny. ^_^ Kana was her usual self...
I know the economy is bad, but are the japanese fans willing to accept such bad animaton? There were bits in this episode that were annoyingly cheaply computer-drawn. v_v